International
Efforts: Conclusions
Widespread
Problems, Widespread Causes
The
problems in Asia and Africa are widespread, causing various health
and environmental hazards that cross national boundaries.
The causes
are widespread as well. A number of different companies
making a wide array of products add to the over all pollution. In
addition, modernization speeds the process. Poverty and population drive
developing nations on both continents, and
worldwide, to industrialize rapidly. In exchange, the rate of pollution
skyrockets as these countries struggle between the old ways and
modernization. A good example is India where they have a massive
population adding to the "brown cloud"
because they are still cooking in open fire using biomass, like dung, as fuel.
In both
cases fixing one company's policy, changing one nation's laws,
won't solve the dilemma, because the effects and causes have spread out
over several nations. Americans especially have problems with widespread
problems, like air pollution, having adopted
a site mentality to pollution control.
Developing
Countries Need Trade
While
the
WTO's focus on trade and market value might seem at face
value to be callus--sacrificing environmental safety to preserve
trade--the WTO is facing a simple fact of the modern world: these
countries need trade. Many of
these countries live under grinding poverty and with poverty comes
massive population growth. The only way to reverse the trends of
over-population and evironmental degradation is to raise the coutnry
out of poverty. Unfortunately, the tools needed to do this, industrial
agriculture and industrialization of labor, come with thier own
environmental drawbacks. In Africa the water
pollution is a direct result of
growing agriculture and industry.
The WTO is
trying to playing the odds, empowering countries to trade in
the hope that they will fix poverty first and the environmental problems later.
Whether
or not this plan is feasible remains to be seen.
Multi-national
Policy
One thing
that has worked is the devlopment of multinational policies
among the affected nations. In the article on African water
pollution such a policy
is detailed. Several nations, "Benin, Côte
d’Ivoire, Ghana, Nigeria, and Togo from Western Africa and Cameroon in
Central Africa", have participated in a program to help stop coastal
pollution. It has met with some success. Perhaps solutions such as this
will work best in the long run. The WTO's policies are tunnel-visioned
on trade and markets leaving nations to take matters into their own
hands, regardless of "green box" policy. |